Unit 2 Positions through iterating

Written by

in

Line of enquiry

The question I am testing, through making:

I am investigating whether the intentional misalignment of Risograph colour layers can reframe printing “error” as a site of authorial agency rather than a deviation to be corrected. Working within a fixed system — three inks, twenty-six graduated offsets of 0.5 millimetres, a hundred and four printed iterations — I ask whether the tolerance zones built into a machine’s calibration routine can be inhabited as expressive material. Each iteration tests a single variable: a direction, a distance, a colour order. The method is deliberately small and formal. I am not asking what the Risograph means; I am asking what happens at the two-and-a-half-millimetre boundary where the machine’s logic of precision meets an operator’s refusal of it. Crucially, the Risograph does not soften the boundaries it prints: every edge remains crisp, every overlap generates a measurable new hue. What I am cataloguing is therefore not a blur and not a glitch, but a geometry — a topology of colour regions whose shape can be precisely described. Through a companion atlas of forty edge samples, I am moving from making misalignment to classifying its morphologies — treating the printed error as a language with its own grammar, rather than as noise to be eliminated before the real image appears.

Annotated Bibliography

  1. “Visual forms of knowledge do not merely display information; they constitute it.” Drucker’s insistence that visualisations are epistemic instruments — not neutral containers for pre-existing facts — gives me a vocabulary for what my Edge Atlas is actually doing. The forty sample pages do not illustrate misalignment after the fact; they produce it as a classifiable phenomenon. Before the atlas exists, a 2.5mm offset is simply a printed sheet. After the atlas, that same offset becomes a member of a taxonomy, comparable to other members, subject to its own internal rules of difference. Drucker lets me see that the move from raw trace to classified specimen is not housekeeping; it is knowledge-making. This changes how I approach layout, pagination, captioning, and indexing. They stop being supporting infrastructure and become the epistemological spine of the work. The atlas is not a document of my iterations; it is the apparatus through which misalignment becomes legible as a subject at all.
  2. “To draw is to go for a walk with a line.” Ingold’s distinction between the line-as-trace — a line that registers a process — and the line-as-connector — a line that joins two points — clarifies what the visible edges in my prints actually are. The boundary where yellow and pink are set not to align is neither a blur between two colour planes nor a connector joining them — it is a trace of a sequence of decisions: a direction set, a drum position, a sheet pulled beneath the print head. Ingold lets me read these edges as inscriptions of process rather than flaws in a product. This shifts my attention from the printed image to the procedural history condensed in its margins. When I catalogue an edge in the atlas, I am preserving not a visual effect but a residue of action. The annotation beneath each sample therefore records what moved, not what appears — closer to a field note than a caption.
  3. “A glitch is a wonderful interruption that shifts an object away from its ordinary form and discourse.” Menkman’s framing of the glitch as a productive rupture — rather than a failure to be hidden — anchors my project’s central claim that the Risograph’s misregistrations are not symptoms of a broken workflow but affordances of an over-determined one. But a fundamental difference emerges on the page. The Risograph does not soften its edges; every boundary remains sharp; there is no moment of apparent machine-failure for a viewer to intercept. What I produce is therefore not a glitch in Menkman’s sense — it is the machine printing exactly as asked, with layers set not to align. But her work also pressures me. She warns that when a glitch is captured, catalogued, and repeated, it risks hardening into an aesthetic signature rather than a critical act. This sharpens my method. I refuse to romanticise the boundary as “accidental beauty”. I insist it is authored, measurable, and reproducible. Each sample in my atlas records exactly what parameter produced it, so that the reader can re-enact the offset rather than merely admire it. This turns Menkman’s glitch from a moment of surprise into something closer to a controlled variable — faithful to her critical spirit, but a small departure from it, since my edges are pre-meditated, not intercepted.
  4. “Print, in the post-digital condition, is valued precisely for what digital reproduction cannot do: produce difference from sheet to sheet.” Ludovico reframes print not as a nostalgic object rescued from the digital age but as a medium whose contemporary value lies precisely in its resistance to exact reproduction. This gives my project its historical position. The Risograph is not a vintage curiosity; it is an instrument that renders material unpredictability visible inside a workflow which otherwise demands conformity. Every sheet differs from the one before it in ways that Photoshop cannot simulate or foresee. Ludovico lets me argue that the misalignment is not a romantic return to the hand — it is a specific, contemporary negotiation with a specific machine, in a specific print culture where “difference” has become the medium’s defining feature. This repositions my hundred and four iterations as arguments about what print is for now: not duplication, but the systematic production of small, legible, measurable differences. The edge, in this reading, is the medium speaking.
  5. “Avoid arbitrary randomness. Difference should have a reason. The process is the product.” The Conditional Design methodology — write a rule, execute it, let the outputs emerge — is the critical scaffold that distinguishes my iterations from stylistic exercises. The manifesto line “difference should have a reason” (also quoted in the Unit 2 brief) is operative here: my 0.5mm increments are not chosen for visual variety but for systematic coverage of the machine’s tolerance range. Yet the book also challenges me. Its authors insist that the rule, not the output, is the work — and my atlas risks fetishising the forty beautiful samples while burying the rule that produced them. Their critique forces me to surface the method itself: the parameter log, the 90-degree direction-rotation convention, the index back to the hundred and four original pages. The written component of this project, and the method page of the atlas, are therefore not supplementary. They are the primary work; the samples are evidence.
  6. “The objects look like sculptures, but they are functional structures.” — Bernd Becher The Bechers’ typological grids — water towers, blast furnaces, winding towers — photographed at identical distance, in identical light, mounted on identical plates, are the deepest reference for my Edge Atlas, though they come from photography, not print. What I take from them is not subject matter but protocol: the assertion that meaning emerges when every variable is held constant except one, and comparison is left to do the theoretical work. My forty sample pages are constructed under a similar discipline — same crop size, same scale, same caption format — so that the viewer’s attention is forced onto the single differing parameter. The Bechers teach me that typology is not a neutral method; it is an argument. By treating misaligned Risograph edges with the seriousness normally reserved for industrial monuments, I am making a quiet claim about what is worth attending to inside a graphic process that most readers would ordinarily skim.

Reference list:

Drucker, J. (2014). Graphesis : visual forms of knowledge production. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Ingold, T. (2016). Lines. Routledge.

Menkman, R. and Geert Lovink (2011). The Glitch moment(um). Amsterdam Institute Of Network Cultures.

Alessandro Ludovico (2018). Post-digital print : the mutation of publishing since 1894. Eindhoven: Onomatopee.

Maurer, L., Edo Paulus, Puckey, J. and Roel Wouters (2013). Conditional design workbook. Amsterdam: Valiz.

Bernd Becher, Hilla Becher and Armin Zweite (2004). Typologies. Cambridge, Mass. London, England Mit Press.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *