Written Response
Our research initially used carbon emissions data from international student air travel as an indicator of the correlation between individual behavior and carbon emissions. However, as I shifted my focus from carbon emissions themselves to a student travel flowchart, I gradually realized that responsibility is assigned by institutional structures. As an international student, I initially viewed travel as a personal choice. However, after refactoring the administrative processes required for enrollment—CAS confirmation, flight allocation, passport checks, and registration—I discovered that travel was not optional, but institutionally mandated; you had to travel to reach your destination.
This shift reshaped my position as a designer within the context of climate justice and the UAL Net-Zero Emissions Initiative. I no longer viewed carbon emissions as a result of a lifestyle, but rather as a tool to explore how systems generate environmental impacts while constructing a framework for individual responsibility. By redesigning the student enrollment process as an “empowered travel package,” I explored how participation in global education inevitably leads to carbon emissions. We redefined travel as accumulated geological traces, with barcodes becoming central to this research: administratively, they record student information; geologically, they become sediment. This transformation allows us to visualize how recurring institutional processes accumulate into traces on Earth, rather than isolated actions.
This project deepened my understanding of the necessity for structural reflection on climate justice within institutions. Therefore, design should be a method to reveal systemic problems, rather than a method to exacerbate individual responsibility.
Bibliography:
- From reading list
Vishmidt, M., Grojs, B., Metahaven (Design Studio and Van, J. (2010). Uncorporate identity. Baden: Lars Müller ; Maastricht.
Explain
Van der Velden and Kroek’s concept of “Uncorporate identity” has profoundly influenced our understanding of how organizations construct abstract concepts through visual systems. This theory posits that organizations cannot be fully seen; they require symbols, signs, and brands to represent their intangible structures. This idea directly prompted a shift from examining the carbon emissions of individual behavior to scrutinizing how institutions create fluidity while concealing their structural roles.
Metahaven’s analysis of how nations and corporations use identity systems during crises helped us re-examine documents like school admissions papers and airline tickets, moving beyond viewing them as neutral administrative documents to see them as tools of empowerment and abstraction. Like corporate identity filling institutional gaps, these documents personalize responsibility while masking systemic dependencies.
Their speculative and analytical approach also validates the effectiveness of refactoring administrative procedures as a design strategy. We are not designing solutions, but revealing the mechanisms of responsibility allocation. This perspective deepens our stance that design is not merely a communication system—it actively shapes how accountability is presented.
Latour, B. (2017). Visualisation and Cognition: Thinking with Eyes and Hands | bruno-latour.fr. [online] Bruno-latour.fr. Available at: http://www.bruno-latour.fr/node/293 [Accessed 26 Feb. 2026].
Explain
Bruno Latour’s Facing Gaia challenges the modernist binary of society and nature, reconstructing the relationship between humanity, institutions, and the planet. In our project, this book helped us shift our understanding of carbon emissions from individual behavior to the systemic conditions that generate them. Latour insists that the planet must be viewed as an active participant (“Gaia”) within a political and epistemological framework, a concept that resonates with our analogy of geological sediments as stacks of bills.
Latour’s emphasis on how institutions and bureaucratic structures regulate human activity and its material consequences provides the theoretical basis for our decision to integrate carbon emissions into administrative documents rather than isolated visual charts. His critique of representation—that visual and textual systems are not neutral but actively shape perception—led us to explore how institutional documents such as CAS letters and bills allocate responsibility. This perspective validates our approach of redefining authorized travel as a venue for responsibility allocation, rather than placing responsibility within individual behavior. Thus, Latour’s research reinforces our view that climate justice involves revealing structural conditions, rather than making moral judgments about individual choices.
- Outside the Reading list
Easterling, K. (2014). Extrastatecraft. Verso Books.
Explain
Keller Easterling’s Extrastatecraft is crucial to understanding how power operates through infrastructure rather than overt political declarations. Easterling argues that the contemporary global system functions through “infrastructure spaces”—spaces containing repeatable formulas, standards, and administrative agreements that subtly organize the movement of people, trade, and governance. This perspective directly influences our shift from viewing emissions as individual acts to examining the procedural structures of empowered flows.
In our project, CAS letters, tickets, and passports are not viewed as symbolic items, but as infrastructure tools. They act as spatial software, authorizing, validating, and facilitating cross-border flows. Easterling’s analysis helps us recognize that these repeatable administrative forms produce material consequences—including carbon emissions—that are not overtly political.
Her concept of “infrastructure as operating system” validates our methodology of reconstructing empowered flows as a series of agreements, rather than individual flight events. This paper redefines student travel as participation in infrastructure systems, rather than individual lifestyle choices, reinforcing our argument that climate justice requires examining the institutional frameworks that subtly generate environmental impacts.
Malm, A. (2016). Fossil Capital. Verso Books.
Explain
Andreas Malm’s Fossil Capital reframes climate change as the result of structural economic decisions rather than collective human behaviour. By tracing the historical shift to steam power in nineteenth-century Britain, Malm argues that fossil fuel dependency was not an inevitable technological evolution but a strategic choice made within capitalist systems to maximise control and profit. This distinction between systemic compulsion and individual agency strongly influenced our project’s conceptual shift.
Initially, we approached student mobility as aggregated personal emissions. Malm’s analysis helped us recognise that large-scale carbon production is embedded in institutional and economic structures long before it appears as individual behaviour. In the context of global higher education, mobility is not simply a lifestyle decision but a structural condition tied to access, competition, and institutional expansion.
Rather than positioning students as primary agents of responsibility, Malm’s work encouraged us to interrogate how systems generate carbon-intensive infrastructures that individuals must navigate. This perspective strengthened our argument that climate justice requires examining the historical and institutional foundations of mobility, rather than reducing emissions to matters of personal morality.
- Design practices/projects
Levenson, J. (2021). Templo teams up with the United Nations to give its latest climate research a cohesive visual identity. [online] www.itsnicethat.com. Available at: https://www.itsnicethat.com/articles/templo-united-nations-graphic-design-031121.
Explain
Templo’s redesign of the United Nations Charter offered a pivotal reference for our project by demonstrating how graphic design can actively interrogate and reframe institutional language rather than merely beautify it. The original Charter is an authoritative legal text—opaque, dense, and associated with global governance—but Templo recasts its structure into three distinct visual grammars that make its underlying protocols, hierarchies, and rhetorical constructions legible. This resonated strongly with our enquiry into how administrative artefacts, such as CAS letters, tickets, and passport records, function not simply as data carriers but as systems that authorise, verify, and normalise states of mobility.
The project influenced both our methodological approach and our conceptual positioning: instead of designing a “carbon visualisation” that would fixate on individual emissions, we began to treat bureaucratic formats themselves as the site of critical design intervention. Templo’s work challenged us to consider how institutional documents are effectively visual infrastructures. Their project validated our decision to adopt speculative administrative design as our strategy, highlighting how the very grammar of official documentation can shape where accountability is perceived, allocated, and experienced.
Tapper, T. (2022). Creativity isn’t carbon neutral: How complicit are agencies in the climate crisis? [online] www.itsnicethat.com. Available at: https://www.itsnicethat.com/articles/nice-and-serious-creativity-isnt-carbon-neutral-opinion-creative-industry-081122.
Explain
Jens Andersen’s opinion piece highlights an important but often overlooked consideration: creative industries are not inherently carbon neutral simply by virtue of communication or aesthetics. Instead, as Andersen argues, the practices, systems, and infrastructures that support creative work itself incur material and energy costs that must be acknowledged rather than obscured. This resonated with our project’s methodological shift away from designing carbon visualisations as neutral representations toward interrogating how visual forms and systems embody and distribute responsibility.
The article encouraged us to reflect on the environmental implications not just of final outputs (e.g., posters, reports, interfaces) but of the underlying procedural and infrastructural conditions that make those outputs possible. In our enquiry, this helped reinforce the idea that design cannot be disentangled from the systems that sustain it; rather than depicting individual emissions as behavioural results, we position design as a tool for making visible the administrative mechanisms that generate and record emissions. Andersen’s critique challenged us to avoid treating data visualisation as an eco-friendly “solution” and instead situate our work within a broader acknowledgement of the creative process’s entanglement with environmental impact. This has influenced how we articulate our environmental stance and frame the project’s critical intervention.
Leave a Reply